Read Our Reviews from Top Rated Dealer In East Brunswick, NJ

Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.

Sort By:

Per Page:

A tale of Fortnite Cole

03/20/2026

5.00

What a wonderful experience I had here at Sheldon Motors. Corey ,Richard and crew are absolutely the best!!!! Such an easy and stress free experience. Great quality cars and great old fashion customer service! Loving my 2010 Toyota Venza.If you are in the market for a quality pre owned car this needs to be your first and only stop!!!Thank you Corey and crew!

S V

03/19/2026

5.00

We had an excellent experience at Sheldon Motors - they had a great selection of vehicles and were very helpful and honest. I would visit again the next time we are in the market for a car!

Anne Alai

03/17/2026

5.00

Cory is a great salesman . From start to finish , he was very helpful

William Newbill

03/13/2026

5.00

John Brede

03/13/2026

5.00

I bought a beautiful FORD F150 and was very happy with my buying experience. Very transparent professional staff fair pricing and no gimmicks or hidden fees. Thank you SHELDON MOTORS

sonya S

03/12/2026

5.00

Cory is the best !! Excellent service

Richard Woodruff II

03/11/2026

5.00

Excellent experience!

steph hague

03/11/2026

5.00

Cecil Peram

03/10/2026

5.00

I had a great buying experience and purchased a great vehicle at a fair price and no gimmicks or hidden fees, Their cars are very clean and the staff is helpful friendly and professional. I highly recommend Sheldon Motors to all my friends and family looking for a great uses car.

James Federico

03/06/2026

5.00

Amazing experience 10/10. I got recommended by my best friend to come here and have had family purchase from sheldon motors in the past and they are honest and very clear with everything! I would recommend this shop to anyone!! they wont BS you like some of the neighboring shops in the area. its more than worth it to pop in and see their options 10/10 would buy from again!!

Customer Testimonials for Sheldon Motors

Brenden C - 2004 TOYOTA RAV 4

I have used Sheldon Motors for both of my purchased vehicles and both times it has been not only easy, but the service and quality of my visits have been superb. 10/10 would recommend. Thank you guys!

S. Negron - 2008 TOYOTA RAV 4

Definite 5 star! The car is in great Shape! Great condition. We have the opportunity to build credit and fix bad credit as well. Thanks to the Wonderful people here, we now have a very reliable car. Thank you so much Sheldon Motors!!

Maria G - 2007 NISSAN ALTIMA

BEST REPUTATION! All the cars I've purchased feel as new as could be! Cory is a very professional and honest person, he is always helpful, I would recommend Sheldon Motors to anyone!

SHELDON MOTORS - SINCE 1954 CAR, TRUCKS, VAN OR SUV

For more then 60 years Sheldon Motors is proud to be best known for offering Quality Pre Owned Cars, Trucks and SUVs at Affordable Prices. In 1942, Sheldon Schiffman established River Motors expanding with three locations on Rt. 46 in Passaic County NJ. In 1954 He established Sheldon Pontiac in New Brunswick. Later with his sons Steven and Cory expanded with a Used car center on Route 18 in East Brunswick NJ. The Schiffman's Experience Fairness and honesty was recognized By the readers of the Home News as Best Pre Owned Dealership in Central New Jersey. Stop by and see why so many of our customers return for their next purchase and Buy with confidence!! We take pride in our Family's Automobile Business. Let our 60 years of experience help put you behind the wheel for next car, truck, van or SUV of your dreams.